If Photography had never been invented, we might be dreaming of it still when we look through windows into the street, through car windscreens or out from our seats on buses, trams and trains. Each of these is an apparatus for making images, the city becoming indelible even as it quickly vacates our vision.
But despite the voraciousness of this vision in motion, the city also gives itself to us half hidden, smeared by movement, by rain or dirt, by the transience of the gaze we bring to bear on it. There is the alchemy of photographic processes that will soon be two centuries old, the blurring or distorting effects of cheap, simple cameras and lenses, the Plato's-cave shadow realm of the camera obscura, and a variety of textured supports for the finished image.
Nowhere more so than in Liebmann's photographs, from the late 1980s to the present, of certain cities. Berlin, London, New York: they appear quite recognizable but occluded, their views and local details transformed or half hidden behind overlapping images, streaming windows, the swarming grain or imperfect resolution of "primitive" techniques and technology.
Liebmann's work smears distinctions between photography and painting, photography and drawing, photography and printmaking, perhaps even photography and writing. Here cities are spectral reminders of themselves, of their histories and their histories of image-making.
Liebmann's blurred, overlapping or seemingly double-exposed pictures give us nothing more or less than the image of imagination. As Woolf puts it, "There is a fixity, a gloom, yet an inner glow that seem to hint that you are looking within and not without."